
By the time the United States is ready to decide whether to prosecute Donald Trump and members of his administration for conduct during his presidency, many Americans may no longer want to talk about it.
That possibility worries me most.
A genuine reckoning could take six years, ten years, or longer. Investigations would have to establish what happened, who made the decisions, who carried them out, and whether crimes were committed. Prosecutors would have to build cases that could withstand court challenges. Trials and appeals could stretch on for years.
Meanwhile, Americans would have lives to live. The imperatives of the 2026 midterm elections would come and go. Other crises would demand attention. The economy might improve. And eventually, the calls to put the past behind us would begin.
I worry that the country will be ready to move on long before the work of justice is finished.
The Long Road to Justice
Consider the timeline we are facing.
Donald Trump’s presidential term is scheduled to end in January 2029. A new Congress could begin investigating his administration in 2027, but a change in congressional control would not put a new attorney general in charge of the Justice Department.
The Justice Department has historically taken the position that a sitting president should not be charged with a crime. Supreme Court decisions in 2024 may limit prosecution of any former presidents.
Those restrictions do not provide blanket protection to everyone who serves in an administration. Nor do they prevent investigations into conduct that is not protected by law.
But they complicate the possibility of a criminal reckoning involving Trump himself.
If a future administration takes office in January 2029, its Justice Department would have to decide what allegations warrant investigation, what evidence is available, and whether criminal charges are justified.
That could be only the beginning.
For many federal crimes, the general statute of limitations is five years. Certain offenses have different deadlines, but for crimes subject to the general rule, conduct occurring in 2025 could face prosecution deadlines beginning in 2030.
The clock is already running.
And a reckoning involving an entire administration would be far more complicated than a single prosecution.
It would require examining individual decisions and responsibilities. Working for Trump would not establish criminal guilt. Neither would supporting his policies. The question would be whether particular individuals committed crimes, authorized unlawful conduct, or knowingly participated in it.
The evidence would have to answer those questions.
That work cannot be completed on an election schedule. And the legal process cannot be shortened simply because Americans want the story to end.
What Happens When Life Gets Better?
Now imagine the country in 2031.
Perhaps inflation has stabilized. The stock market is performing well. Unemployment is low. Families feel more financially secure. The political atmosphere is quieter.
Americans are enjoying a return to something resembling normal life.
Then the Justice Department announces another investigation involving the Trump administration. Or a prosecutor brings charges against a former senior official. Or a long-running case finally reaches trial.
What happens then?
Will Americans still demand answers? Will they tolerate years of legal proceedings, appeals, and arguments over evidence? Will they keep paying attention when cases are complicated and outcomes uncertain?
Or will they begin asking why the country cannot simply move on?
Some will argue that continued investigations reopen old wounds. Some will say the country needs unity. Others will argue that pursuing former officials is political retaliation.
Concerns about politically motivated prosecutions deserve serious attention. Criminal charges must rest on evidence and law, not political disagreement. Defendants are entitled to the presumption of innocence and a fair trial.
But those principles cannot become an excuse to abandon credible evidence of criminal conduct.
A country becoming tired of confronting wrongdoing does not make the wrongdoing disappear.
And an improving economy cannot tell us whether government officials obeyed the law.
A country can become more prosperous without becoming more just.
We Have Seen This Before
In September 1974, President Gerald Ford granted Richard Nixon a sweeping pardon for federal offenses he had committed or might have committed during his presidency.
Nixon had resigned a month earlier amid the Watergate scandal. The pardon ensured that he would not face federal criminal prosecution for the conduct it covered.
Ford believed the country needed to move beyond Watergate. He viewed the pardon as a way to end a painful national ordeal.
Some of Nixon’s associates were prosecuted and imprisoned. Congressional investigations and public reporting established an extensive record of wrongdoing. But Nixon himself never stood trial for federal crimes arising from his presidency.
Ford’s decision remains a powerful example of the tension between the desire for national healing and the pursuit of justice.
It also raises a question that Americans may face again.
When a former president’s conduct is at issue, who decides that the country has suffered enough and should move on?
History also offers a different example.
Argentina began prosecuting leaders of its former military dictatorship in 1985. Political resistance, restrictive laws, and presidential pardons interrupted the pursuit of justice. Yet victims’ families, human rights organizations, and others continued pressing for answers.
Decades later, criminal prosecutions resumed. Many former officials were eventually convicted.
Argentina’s experience is not a blueprint for the United States. Its history, legal system, and the crimes involved were different.
But it demonstrates something important: A reckoning can survive years of resistance and delay when people refuse to abandon it.
Justice was not inevitable. People kept pursuing it.
The Lesson We Leave Our Children
Another consequence of abandoning a reckoning troubles me even more than the failure to punish individual wrongdoing.
It is what the next generation learns about the law.
We teach children that rules apply to everyone. We tell them that people must take responsibility for their actions and that serious wrongdoing carries consequences.
But children also learn from what adults actually do.
What lesson do we teach when powerful people can avoid legal consequences simply because holding them responsible has become inconvenient?
What do young Americans learn when allegations against ordinary citizens are pursued through the courts, but credible evidence against the politically powerful is left unexamined because the country wants to move on?
They learn that the rules are different for people with power.
They learn that political influence can provide protection unavailable to everyone else.
And perhaps most dangerously, they learn that time itself can become a defense. If someone can delay the process long enough, the public may lose interest, political leaders may lose their resolve, and the opportunity for prosecution may disappear.
That is not a lesson any democracy should want to pass to its children.
Equal justice under the law cannot depend on how wealthy someone is, which political party they belong to, or how much public attention their case receives.
The presumption of innocence must apply to everyone. So must the obligation to answer for crimes that can be proved.
A Reckoning Cannot Depend on Public Enthusiasm
I do not expect Americans to spend the next decade consumed by anger. People have families to support, jobs to do, and their own futures to build.
Nor should justice require the public to remain in a permanent state of outrage.
That is why we have courts, prosecutors, investigators, and laws. Their responsibility is to apply the law even when the public has turned its attention elsewhere.
But institutions do not operate in a political vacuum.
Presidents appoint attorneys general. Elected officials determine budgets and priorities. Prosecutors exercise discretion. Political leaders also understand when the public has stopped demanding answers.
A future administration could decide that investigating its predecessor’s conduct would take too much time, invite too much controversy, or interfere with its own agenda.
It could call that decision an act of national healing.
But healing is different from deciding not to confront what happened.
A genuine reckoning would not guarantee that Trump or any member of his administration would be convicted of a crime. No honest legal process can promise that result in advance.
It would mean credible allegations received serious examination, evidence was preserved, criminal charges were brought wherever justified, and those charges were resolved through the courts.
It would mean refusing to exempt political power from legal scrutiny.
And it would mean having the determination to keep that work going after the public stops finding it interesting.
Because the greatest danger may not be that Americans openly reject the idea of a reckoning.
It may be that we embrace it passionately for a year or two, then gradually abandon it as our circumstances improve.
A stronger economy will not erase unlawful government conduct. A quieter political environment will not establish innocence. And the passage of time will not turn an unresolved crime into something that never happened.
If powerful people discover that they can escape justice simply by waiting for Americans to lose interest, we will have taught future leaders exactly how to do it again.
That is the consequence of an abandoned reckoning.
And no amount of economic prosperity can repair it.
