This is the final installment of How American Democracy Backslid, a five-part Dispatches from Kentucky investigation into the decisions and institutional failures that weakened American democracy.

On September 24, 2025, a federal judge issued a blunt finding about President Donald Trump’s dismissal of independent government watchdogs.
“President Trump violated the IGA. That much is obvious.”
IGA stands for the Inspector General Act, the federal law governing officials who investigate fraud, waste, abuse, and misconduct within government agencies.
Congress had strengthened that law in 2022. It required the president to give Congress at least 30 days’ notice and a detailed explanation before removing an inspector general.
In January 2025, Trump dismissed numerous inspectors general without following those requirements.
Eight went to court seeking reinstatement.
Judge Ana Reyes agreed that the president had violated the law. But she denied their request to return to their positions, finding that they had not met the legal requirements for that remedy.
The law had been violated. A court recognized the violation. Yet that decision did not reinstate the eight officials.
The case illustrates a fundamental problem at the heart of American democratic backsliding.
Having a law that limits government power is not the same as ensuring that the law actually restrains those who exercise it.
Throughout this series, we have examined how American democratic institutions were weakened.
State lawmakers changed election rules. Donald Trump and his associates attempted to overturn the 2020 presidential election. Political incentives influenced how Congress and voters responded. Presidential control over federal institutions expanded.
The final question is why the safeguards intended to prevent or correct these actions did not consistently work.
The evidence reveals four connected problems.
1. Officials used governmental power to weaken democratic constraints
The first issue involved officials in charge of agencies and systems that are, or should be, supportive of democracy.
In 2013, North Carolina’s Republican legislature passed laws to restrict voting.
The restrictions, which were ruled discriminatory and blocked by a federal court, were targeted to affect voting methods used more by Black citizens.
After the 2020 presidential election, which they lost, Trump and his supporters, including some Republican officials, rejected and attempted to undermine the election results. Trump urged and pressured officials to reverse their support for, and participation in, the election process; he and others organized alternative ways for state and federal election officials to certify election results; and they planned to change the process by which elected Members of Congress represent their state’s interests in counting Electoral College votes. Trump and his allies’ efforts to maintain power despite losing the presidential election demonstrated a disregard for the democratic process and rule of law.
The effort failed. Joe Biden’s victory was certified, and presidential power transferred.
Beginning in January 2025, the Trump administration expanded presidential control over federal agencies, removed independent oversight officials, changed civil-service protections, and took funding actions that the Government Accountability Office subsequently found violated federal law.
These events did not involve identical legal violations or produce identical outcomes.
But they demonstrate a recurring feature of American democratic deterioration.
As with the Trump Administration, other federal officials, whether acting alone or in concert, altered, amended, and disregarded the laws that established and restricted their authority.
These actions demonstrate the decay of American democracy.
2. Political accountability did not consistently discourage those actions
Accountability in a constitutional system takes many forms.
Congress can hold officials accountable through investigation and oversight.
Ultimately, voters can remove officials from office at the ballot box.
Political parties can foster accountability by rewarding or punishing candidates for their leadership and support.
Still, accountability by these means did not prevent the undermining of the 2020 election and the January 6 insurrection.
In fact, the 117th Congress responded to January 6 with accountability measures that cut across the aisle.
After the House impeached Trump for inciting the insurrection, the Senate held a trial.
Although the Constitution requires a two-thirds vote for conviction, some Senators argued that a former President cannot be prosecuted, effectively lowering the threshold to impose punishment. Ultimately, the former President was not convicted.
In response to the trial outcome and the failure of other accountability measures, a number of House and Senate Democrats proposed establishing an independent commission to investigate January 6. Like the legislation creating the commission, several procedures and practices were created to respond to Trump’s incitement of the insurrection.
Still, political accountability ultimately fell to the voters.
Bartels and Carnes studied the 2022 midterm elections to determine the effects of the 2020 election challenges on the GOP House members that endorsed and supported them.
They studied the effects of Trump’s election-related efforts on lawmakers.
Most lawmakers suffered no adverse electoral consequences for supporting those efforts. Some even gained political benefits.
Other Republican lawmakers who criticized Trump suffered political consequences, such as losing their party leadership positions and/or being challenged in a primary.
The researchers cannot say why individual lawmakers and voters supported or opposed efforts to challenge Trump’s election.
However, the consequences of those election-related actions of lawmakers are documented.
Several Republican lawmakers supported efforts to challenge the results of the 2020 election; however, there is no evidence those lawmakers suffered greater consequences than Republican lawmakers who opposed those efforts.
Lawmakers must face adverse consequences for their actions to maintain the integrity of the electoral process.
3. Finding a legal violation did not necessarily correct the damage
Three problems have been identified as a result of the inspector general case.
First, Congress passed legislation to address the problem. Then the president took actions that violated the law. Finally, a court case was filed to challenge the president’s actions, and the judges recognized that the president violated the law. However, the court refused to order the president to reinstate the dismissed officials.
Judge Reyes noted that the president has the authority to take the actions challenged in the case; however, the judge also recognized that the plaintiffs failed to provide a sufficient basis to order other types of legal relief.
Judge Reyes’ analysis was consistent with jurisprudence; however, from the perspective of the officials challenged in the case, the outcome was less than satisfactory.
A similar issue arose in federal spending.
This case addresses the spending powers of Congress and the executive branch. Under the Constitution, Congress holds the power over federal spending.
However, the executive branch has the power to veto spending. The Impoundment Control Act authorizes Congress to challenge the president’s decision to withhold spending.
In August 2025, the Government Accountability Office determined that the president and the Department of Health and Human Services violated the Act by withholding spending appropriated to the National Institutes of Health.
On October 7, 2026, GAO reported another instance of the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) failing to follow laws and regulations. AHRQ stopped processing grants after staff reductions. It also withheld funds appropriated for those grants.
GAO concluded that, in doing so, AHRQ broke the law.
However, they do not, in and of themselves, ensure recovery of the funds withheld.
The Comptroller General of the United States, as provided by law, may institute an action in a court of competent jurisdiction to enforce a granting agency’s obligation to pay out funds appropriated by Congress.
The important question is whether such a process promptly corrects the violation and negates its effects.
A law may have been broken, and its effects may remain unabated.
This situation is particularly troubling for the safeguards of a democracy.
It may be that a law has been broken, and an independent entity has concluded that this is the case; however, the true test of the effectiveness of democratic safeguards lies in what corrective actions are taken.
4. Courts changed some of the legal protections themselves
The fourth issue was different from the others.
Certain legal frameworks changed, and that required the Supreme Court to make different kinds of decisions.
In June 2026, the Court handed down its decision in Trump v. Slaughter.
The case challenged the president’s power to remove members of the Federal Trade Commission.
The Court decided that those constraints were unconstitutional because they impinged on the president’s power to remove commission members who exercise executive authority.
The Court concluded that because Commission members exercise executive authority, the president should have the power to remove them.
Judges who support the deregulatory position embraced the president’s argument. They held that the constraints on the president’s power to remove members of the Commission were unconstitutional.
The Court upheld the president’s power to remove Commission members.
While the Court’s ruling was not illegal, it altered the legal framework, and the Commission suffered the most.
A protection Congress enacted to shield regulatory agencies from presidential control was construed more narrowly.
The Supreme Court case Trump v. CASA (2025) overturned lower federal court decisions and limited the relief federal district courts could grant.
Universal injunctions, which restrain government officers from enforcing or implementing a law, were no longer allowable.
Courts retain the discretion to grant other forms of judicial relief.
The court cases illustrated different methods of democratic accountability.
Because the cases raised different issues about interpreting the U.S. Constitution and Federal statutes, the outcome may have turned on judicial interpretations of the law.
Such interpretations may alter the scope of legal protections and the power of government institutions.
Although courts may rule against a party and fail to protect that party from government action, such a ruling may constrain how that government agency acts.
It may also alter the types of relief courts may provide in similar cases in the future.
Some safeguards held
There is not enough evidence to support the claim that American democratic institutions collapsed or stopped functioning.
Many of the safeguards described in this series functioned as designed.
For example, in North Carolina, the federal courts ruled that recently enacted voting restrictions were unconstitutional and discriminatory.
Following the 2020 presidential election, under significant political pressure, Georgia’s election officials upheld the election outcome.
Likewise, career attorneys in the Department of Justice refused to support baseless claims that the 2020 election was corrupt.
Vice President Pence also refused to act outside the law when he was directed to reject election results.
The Joint Session of Congress, which includes members of the Electoral College, also upheld the election results.
Following the 2020 election, Congress passed the Electoral Count Act of 2022 to clarify and amend the procedures governing the counting of presidential electoral votes.
Congress subsequently enacted the Electoral Count Reform Act of 2022, clarifying the vice president’s limited role and strengthening procedures governing the counting of presidential electoral votes.
American democratic institutions often demonstrate flexibility and the potential for positive change.
These developments, however, should not be expected.
Most recently, changes to election laws have aimed to limit voting.
What this means for Kentucky
This is not just a concern for Washington.
Kentucky’s legislators control the state laws that govern voting and the process by which state legislative and congressional districts are created. Members of Kentucky’s congressional delegation participate in the federal process that transfers presidential power.
Kentucky courts review the limits of Kentucky state officials’ authority.
Kentucky citizens, universities, businesses, and other organizations rely on various social, public health, infrastructure, and other federal assistance and services created under the laws passed by Congress.
From the perspective of the people of Kentucky, the significance of the functions of the various branches of the federal government does not depend on which political party controls them.
The people of Kentucky have an interest in the actions of federal agencies and departments in implementing laws passed by Congress.
The people of Kentucky have an interest in how federal agencies administer laws created by Congress.
Kentuckians have an interest in the actions of federal agents and prosecutors in investigating potential illegal activities by federal employees.
The people of Kentucky have an interest in the actions of state and local officials that affect the rules by which political candidates compete.
Why American democracy backslid
This series started with a basic question: why has democracy declined in the United States?
The five studies include relevant details and findings.
Between 2019 and 2021, various state officials changed election laws and rules, restricted representation, and adopted discriminatory policies.
Courts later challenged these policies.
President Trump and other officials attempted to overturn his 2020 election defeat.
Some lawmakers defended and maintained democratic procedures and processes, while others attacked them.
Beginning in 2021, various presidential executive orders and directives changed and restricted various rules and processes to control federal government institutions. Many of these orders and directives conflicted with and ran contrary to established laws.
No adequate checks and balances existed to reverse these actions.
Courts and/or the President’s appointees changed many laws and rules that constrained the President’s power.
This series’ findings and conclusions are based on the five events covered in the study.
Each of these events, in varying degrees, modified and constrained the checks and balances of the federal government, amended the separation of powers, and incorporated and expanded authoritarian and autocratic practices.
These five events, and many others, showed that democratic norms and constraints can be changed to advance and protect autocratic practices.
Before we can understand repair
It is important to distinguish surviving backsliding from eliminating its root causes.
We can survive attempts to subvert democratic norms. The 2020 election shows this. However, exposing weaknesses does not mean they no longer exist.
The protection of inspectors general was strengthened. However, laws and regulations continue to be relaxed to expand executive power.
Adequate controls were eliminated. Legislative and judicial oversight bodies investigate executive violations of the law.
Consider the cases and decisions in our series to better understand the current state of our democratic norms and institutions.
What assurances do we have that Congress will pursue the laws broken by the President?
What reinforced safeguards will keep the President and Congress accountable to the rule of law?
Will controls on the Presidency and Executive Branch remain in place for the next administration?
Will the legislative and judicial branches hold the President accountable for breaking the law?
We do not know what the future will bring. We can not completely trust the actions of politicians, the will of the people, or how the institutions of the land will adapt and change over time.
Regarding the recovery of the American system of representative democracy, history’s lessons will not effectively serve us in constructing a strategy for the future.
While writing these articles, I came to understand certain principles.
The rule of law is not enough to protect a democracy by stipulating the bounds of legal authority. Those bounds must be observed and enforced. It is also important that transgressing those bounds results in consequences and penalties.
Ultimately, the American democratic system depended for its safety on the will and choices of the people who designed and adapted it, and on the decisions of the people who interpreted and enforced its various provisions.
Safeguards were challenged, breached, or changed, and their effectiveness depended on the decisions of the officials and institutions responsible for upholding them.
If we recognize and understand the causes that contributed to the decline of American democracy, we can identify similar causes that will threaten the efficacy of any proposed remediation.
This will enable us to assess democratic ‘repair’ efforts.
This will allow us to continue our investigation into the principles of democratic repair.
Sources and documentation
Independent oversight and enforcement
GAO, National Institutes of Health funding decision, August 5, 2025
GAO, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality funding decision, October 7, 2026
Congressional and electoral accountability
Bartels and Carnes, House Republicans Were Rewarded for Supporting Donald Trump’s ‘Stop the Steal’ Efforts, PNAS (2023)
Judicial authority
Democratic deterioration
