
On Wednesday, the Ethics Commission in Louisville filed a lawsuit to prevent the state from removing them from office at the end of the year.
The Ethics Commission looks into conflicts of interest and other ethics violations by local politicians. State legislators recently passed a bill that sets each Ethics Commission member’s term to end on December 31st of this year.
Members of the Ethics Commission believe this law is unconstitutional.
They believe the state is attempting to replace the Ethics Commission before it can investigate state legislators for possible violations of the state’s ethics laws. Judicial proceedings initiated by the Ethics Commission have recently been successful.
Last week, the Jefferson Circuit Court Judge Ann Bailey Smith denied an attempt by the Jefferson County Attorney’s Office to dismiss the Ethics Commission’s lawsuit. Now, the state is free to require Louisville to remove its ethics commission. Whether the court will stop the state remains to be seen.
What the legislature changed
House Bill 607 became law on April 14, 2026, after Republican legislators overturned Governor Beshear’s veto.
The law amends many aspects of Louisville Metro Government’s governance.
Relevant to the Ethics Commission’s legal challenge are amendments affecting the appointment process and the Commission’s access to legal counsel.
Currently, the Metro Mayor appoints Ethics Commission members, who are later rubber-stamped by Metro Council. With this change, the Metro Mayor would appoint three members of the Commission, with each of the two largest caucuses of Metro Council appointing the remaining two members. Of the appointees, no more than three may be of the same political party.
The current members of the Commission would be terminated on December 31st of this year.
The amended act also changes how the Ethics Commission retains legal representation.
If the Commission needs legal services, it must be represented by attorneys employed in the County Attorney’s office, or the attorney must retain outside counsel.
Employees of the County Attorney’s office are also bound by Louisville’s ethics rules.
Thus, to obtain legal advice on how to investigate a government official, employees of the County Attorney’s office are instructed to represent the Commission; otherwise, there is a conflict of interest.
Why the commission says the law is unconstitutional
At Wednesday’s hearing, attorney Todd Lewis, representing the Kentucky legislative commission, asserted that HB 607 violates restrictions in Kentucky’s constitution on ‘log rolling’ or enactment of one piece of legislation to benefit another.
Sections 59 and 60 of the Kentucky Constitution restrict the General Assembly from enacting laws that affect only a single locality without broader legislation.
Lewis contended that the bill’s provisions eliminating the Ethics Commission were specific to Louisville.
The commission has also taken issue with the portion of the bill that changes the county attorney position to investigate potential violations of the code of ethics, claiming it negatively impacts the separation of powers.
Supporters of the bill have denied that the changes effectively reduce or weaken accountability.
Representative Chris Lewis, the bill’s sponsor, previously said he wanted to amend the balance of party representation on the ethics commission to prevent one party from controlling it.
It has been rightly suggested that members of an ethics commission should not be from the same party as the officials being investigated to maintain the commission’s integrity. The new law still requires Louisville to have an ethics commission.
The court will decide whether the new structure of that commission violates the Kentucky Constitution.
What the court has done so far
The Ethics Commission began legal proceedings against the state in May, after HB 607 passed.
Jefferson County’s Attorney General’s office stated that, as part of Louisville Metro government, the Ethics Commission does not have the authority to initiate a lawsuit.
Judge Smith recently denied this argument and allowed the Ethics Commission to proceed with its lawsuit against the state.
Smith’s decision does not indicate that Judge Smith believes HB 607 to be unconstitutional. On Wednesday, the Ethics Commission requested a temporary injunction to stop the state from implementing the law’s substitute provisions while the lawsuit is pending.
The Kentucky Attorney General’s Office will represent the state and defend the law’s constitutionality by the December 2 deadline.
The Ethics Commission has until that time to respond. In the meantime, the Ethics Commission continues to operate. No injunction has yet been issued.
The decision that matters now
This case touches on which government body gets to set the rules for another.
Kentucky lawmakers can create rules for local government. However, they have the greater responsibility to abide by the state constitution.
The Ethics Commission in Louisville must investigate potential breaches of the local ethics code. To do so, it must operate independently of the subject of the investigation.
Thus, this situation falls under the ‘Attack independent institutions’ pattern of power. The Kentucky legislature’s recent action to restructure the Ethics Commission, in effect, altered the Commission’s scope and membership. Whether this restructuring violates the law is yet to be determined.
In the meantime, the Ethics Commission has rightfully taken legal action to challenge the state law.
That response has done nothing more than allow the commission’s lawsuit to continue.
It has not prevented the replacement of commission members.
Residents of Louisville should call members of the Metro Council to ask how they will examine potential appointees to the commission to determine whether they have any conflicts of interest. These calls should be made prior to the members of the Metro Council voting to confirm any appointees to the commission.
Residents have the right to make these requests regardless of the lawsuit’s outcome.
At this point, Judge Smith has the final say. Arguments supporting the Attorney General’s position will be filed on December 2nd. The commission will file response briefs thereafter.
Absent a court order, the commission members’ current terms will expire on December 31st. The General Assembly has already eliminated the commission and determined how it will handle ethics oversight for Louisville.
Now the court must decide whether it has the authority to intervene.
Sources and further reading
Louisville Public Media, November 18, 2026: Court hears arguments on Ethics Commission challenge
Kentucky General Assembly: HB 607 legislative history and enacted documents
Kentucky Acts Chapter 165: Enacted text of HB 607
Louisville Public Media, March 2: Original proposal and sponsor’s explanation
Louisville Public Media, May 28: Ethics Commission litigation
